PB&J Cookie Sandwich

Relive childhood memories with a gourmet twist in our PB&J Cookie Sandwich. Two peanut butter cookies embrace a generous dollop of strawberry jam and creamy peanut butter, dusted with powdered sugar for a nostalgic treat that's all grown up.

Makes

12 Cookies

Ingredients

Otis Spunkmeyer Peanut Butter Cookies

Strawberry Jam

Peanut Butter

Powdered Sugar

Preparation

Cook and cool the peanut butter cookies according to package directions. Allow to cool before proceeding to fill.
To make one sandwich, turn one of the cookies upside down so the bottom is facing up. Top with a dollop of jam. Take another cookie and dollop with peanut butter and sandwich the cookies together.
Top with powdered sugar.
Repeat with the remaining cookies.

Recipe Idea

Chocolate Checkerboard Blondie

Little effort with a big, delicious impact. These two-tone bar cookies couldn’t be simpler to prepare; made with contrasting chocolate cookies and cut into squares—that’s it! Every homemade bite is either ultra-chocolately...

Recipe Idea

Pink Ribbon Cookie

Honor Breast Cancer Awareness Month by decorating our cookies with an edible pink icing ribbon. A perfect opportunity to show off your icing skills.

Recipe Idea

Gingersnap Espresso Cookie

The perfect pick-me-up! Chocolate, ginger, and espresso come together in one seriously delicious, elevated cookie that’s easy to whip up at a moment’s notice. Chocolate and espresso is a winning combo, and...

Get Inspired

Find out how Otis Spunkmeyer

can help you